The Diet Industry

Today I would like to congratulate Geoffrey Cannon on the release of his book stating the blatantly obvious for anyone with two brain cells to rub together; ‘Dieting Makes You Fat’.

There is, of course, a slight misnomer in the title anyway, as all ways of eating are types of diet; but I’ll let him get away with that today.

The clue really is in the title of this blog, the diet ‘industry’. Without the millions of us suckers believing that by taking a course of tablets that contain an amphetamine (similar to speed) or by cutting back on a food group or worse still only eating one food group; that they will be the answer to all of our weight retention worries.

These things of course will work. If you are eating less than your body needs to run itself or taking a substance that temporarily makes your body’s metabolism speed up, then indeed you will begin to burn the fat you’re storing. This is why it works quite quickly; you’re body thinks you’re starving to death so starts using the stored resources to keep you running.

Now, here’s another obvious thing. If you have informed your body you are starving to death, the food you are eating will be broken down differently to last you longer. This by-product of the slimming diet is of course inconsequential as you watch the weight fall off.

Now, if the type of diet you had before this slimming diet made you fat, why would it not make you fat again when you finish the slimming diet and return to it?

Quite simply, it will. You were eating an imbalanced diet and not doing enough exercise, which is why you were fat.

Now there is an extra dimension to the problem. As you start eating normally again, you’re body is still running like you are starving to death. So your food intake goes up and your body stores even more of it than before, to make very sure that when the food runs out again, you will be able to go on for longer.

So, the weight goes back on, another season starts and the diet industry tells you that yet again, you are just too fat and ugly. The last slimming diet didn’t work…but you’re sure the next one definitely will.

Geoffrey Cannon, in his new book, states the supurbly obvious। If you want to get slimmer and healthier then take a long hard look at your lifestyle. Only you has made you fat, no-one else. You can’t blame McDonalds or Burger King or companies who make the ready meals you buy because you’re ‘just too busy’ to put pasta in a sauce pan or a potato in the oven and just ‘too tired’ to do a bit of exercise twice a week. They don’t come to your house, tie you down and make you swallow.

The only one to blame is you and your lazyness. It’s far easier to keep doing the fad diets and blame the world for your inadequacies than take responsibility for yourself.

7 comments:

Unknown said...

You would think people would realize by now that if there was a magic cure, there wouldn't be fat people anymore. The only thing that works is a lifestyle you can stick to - moderate eating and moderate exercise. If you try to eat too little and do too much exercise it won't last. Moderation is the key.

philip said...

While I understand your comment about the fast food chains, let me ask you a question. Wouldn't it be better if those chains had a wider selection of healthier choices? That way people could get healthier foods fast too.

kfaisal said...

wow there.. i never thought of dieting from this perspective before.. you had really gave me a knock on the head ;p
Thanks for the wake up call!! :D

Angel said...

I agree that being overweight is each person's own fault. I know I eat the wrong things for my body and don't move enough. I'm trying to remedy the situation as we speak(write).

I have diabetes and have to follow a low carb diet. I sometimes have a hard time understanding why people without health problems can't lose weight. If all I had to do was cut down on my calories and exercise to lose weight I'd be skinny already.

It's still my own fault that I'm not though. I know I have to eat low carb, so I just need to do it! Even though it's no fun and hard to stick to. My health is worth it.
Giving myself a little pep talk there.

Great post!

Carol said...

For some reason, our culture seems to pander to those who refuse a healthier way of doing things. Health food stores struggle, unable to remain afloat while donut shops thrive.

The problem with carbs is we crave them. Most Americans, thanks to the Standard American Diet, have an overabundance of Candida living in our digestive systems. Candida needs sugar to survive. The byproducts of Candida stimulate a craving for carbs which, when converted metabolically, produce food for the Candida. Thus the cycle continues.

It takes 40 days to completely break the cycle. And the sugar highs and lows from the carbs stress our adrenal glands. We have less energy, feel more stressed, and are, therefore, less likely to exercise.

So, we're basically addicts.

Nice blog.

gone said...

I agree. Just a healthy lifestyle would fix most of us. I am hopefully on the road to recovery. I do consider it just has bad as being a alcoholic or drug user (well, in a different sense). The addiction is still there and control has to be regained at some point.

Mike Golch said...

this is a good posting,the thing that everyone does not relize is that there is no "magic bulet" the best way to lose weight is a balanced diet and whatching how much you eat,Portion control and exercise will help you lose and keep the weight off.I call this the common sense diet.